Ask a seller which courier is best and you will get a strong opinion. Ask why, and it usually traces back to one memorable disaster or one helpful account manager. Neither is data.

The real answer is that the question is wrong. There is no best courier. There is a best courier for a destination, and the gap between them is where your return rate lives.

Averages hide the thing you need

For example, a courier reporting an 82% delivery success rate nationally may be running 91% in Karachi and 58% in a smaller city where it has thin coverage. Booked blind, every parcel to that second city carries a hidden penalty — and because the average looks acceptable, nothing ever flags it.

Three numbers matter per city, not nationally:

Delivery success rate — of parcels sent there, how many actually got delivered.

Return rate — how many came back, with all the cost that carries.

Average days — how long it took, which drives both cancellations and "where is my order" messages.

What thin coverage actually means on the ground

It is worth understanding why the same company performs so differently a few hundred kilometres apart, because it tells you which gaps are likely to close and which are structural.

A courier's strong cities are usually the ones with a company-run hub and salaried riders who work the same neighbourhoods every day. They know which lanes are which, they recognise repeat addresses, and they will attempt a delivery twice because it is their round.

Weaker cities are often served through a franchise or an onward-booking arrangement with a smaller local operator. The parcel is handed over, and your courier's own tracking becomes a report of someone else's work. Attempts are fewer, phone calls are briefer, and a customer who was out on the first attempt becomes a return rather than a second visit.

This is why a weak city tends to stay weak until the company opens a hub there, and why asking your account manager a direct question — "is this city your own operation or a franchise?" — is often more informative than any promise about improvement.

Why your own data is not enough on its own

If you send forty parcels a month to a city, your own success rate there is close to meaningless — one bad week swings it entirely. The pattern only becomes trustworthy at volume most single sellers do not have.

Revebe ERP benchmarks this anonymously across stores running on the platform, in its courier tracking and city performance report. No store sees another store's orders, customers or figures; what surfaces is the aggregate behaviour of a courier in a city, which is precisely the thing no individual seller has enough data to see alone.

From that comes a recommended courier per city — not an opinion, an observed pattern.

Read the three numbers together

A single number will mislead you, and the combinations are more informative than any one of them.

High success, slow days. The parcels arrive, eventually. This is tolerable for a planned purchase and corrosive for an impulse one, because the customer has had a week to change their mind and will take delivery of a decision they no longer want — or refuse it.

Fast days, high returns. Often a sign of minimal attempts. The parcel moves quickly to the city and quickly back. Speed here is not a service level; it is a short attempt window.

Good success, poor at a particular size. Bulky or heavy parcels can perform quite differently from small ones on the same route, because they travel differently and get handled differently. If your catalogue spans both, check them separately rather than as one pool.

The other decision the numbers unlock

Choosing a courier is the obvious use. There is a second one that saves more money and gets considered less.

Some destinations are poor on every available service. For those, the useful question is not which courier to book but whether to offer cash on delivery there at all. A city where one parcel in three comes back is a city where COD is costing you both legs of the shipping on a third of your orders, plus the handling, plus the stock sitting in transit. Tracking those returns per city is part of COD and returns management.

Offering prepaid only for those destinations — with a small discount to make it palatable — converts a loss-making route into a smaller but profitable one. Sellers resist this because it feels like turning away business. The arithmetic usually disagrees.

A caution worth keeping

Courier performance is not fixed. A service that was poor in a city last year may have opened a hub there since; one that was excellent may have lost its best riders. This is a number to re-read quarterly, not a decision to make once and defend forever.

The point of measuring per city is not to crown a winner. It is to stop treating a national average as if it described your parcel.

Frequently asked questions

Which courier is best in Pakistan? No single courier is best everywhere. Compare delivery success rate, return rate and average days for each destination city, and book the courier that performs best in that city.

How many parcels do I need before a city's numbers mean anything? A few dozen parcels a month is too few; one bad week swings the result. That is why a benchmark pooled anonymously across many stores is more reliable than one store's own history.

Should I stop offering cash on delivery in some cities? Where every courier returns a large share of parcels, offering prepaid only, perhaps with a small discount, often turns a loss-making route into a profitable one.

How often should I re-check courier performance by city? At least every quarter. Couriers open hubs and lose riders, so last year's ranking can be wrong today.